Catholic University of America

The winner of the 2025 Outstanding Men's Senior Athlete Award was Jevontae Fearwell.
 

Year	Name	Sport
1994	Dan Kuebler	Track & Field
1995	John Douglas	Basketball/Baseball
1996	Brent Raue	Swimming
1997	Matthew Taylor	Football
1998	Jeff Clay	Football
1998	Kevin Ricca	Football
1999	Sean Tuohey	Basketball
2000	Dan Harrington	Basketball
2001	Patrick Maloney	Basketball
2002	Derek McGee	Football
2003	Matthew Hilleary	Basketball
2004	William Morley	Basketball
2005	Andrew Kelly	Tennis
2006	Connor Kelly	Lacrosse
2007	Patrick Dwyer	Basketball
2008	Mike Goodman	Football/Baseball
2009	Keith Ricca	Football
2010	Matt Brady	Soccer
2011	Jason Banzhaf	Basketball
2012	Timothy Mierzwa	Baseball
2013	Michael Brennan	Soccer
2014	Kevin Romano	Soccer
2015	Torsten Meuschke	Soccer
2016	Bryson Fonville	Basketball
2017	Tim Keith	Lacrosse
2018	Jay Howard	Basketball
2019	Jon Mierzwa	Baseball
2020	Mike Narzikul	Soccer
2021	Ben Alexander	Soccer
2022	Kevin Crowley	Lacrosse
2023	Tucker Alch	Baseball
2024	Jesse Hafemeister	Basketball
2025	Jevontae Fearwell	Track & Field